01
The listing does this
Being found by somebody who does not know your name
Somebody in Massey types the trade and the suburb into a phone. What comes back first is the map, and what is in the map is listings rather than websites. If you are not in it you are not in the running, and no amount of website fixes that on its own.
What a free Google listing doesNearly all of it. Being in the map result is a listing job, and one published estimate has only about a third of small businesses with a profile at all.
What a site addsSomething for the searches the map does not answer — the job written out by name, which is how you turn up for "replace a hot water cylinder" rather than only for "plumber near me".
02
The listing does this
Being believed by a stranger
A stranger decides whether you are legitimate in about ten seconds, and mostly he does it on reviews and photographs. Published research on the point is blunt: the most common reason people give for not ringing a local business at all is something about its reviews. Price is not in the reasons.
What a free Google listing doesAll of it, and better than a website can. Reviews are not yours to write, which is exactly why they are believed.
What a site addsVery little to this one. A site with no reviews behind it is a well-dressed stranger. Get the reviews first.
03
The listing mostly does this
Being reachable at the moment somebody decides
The decision is usually made on a phone, one-handed, and often outside your working hours. What it needs is a number that rings, hours that are right, and an answer to "are you open now".
What a free Google listing doesThe phone call, the hours and the directions, which is most of it. Keeping the public holidays right on there is worth more than most of a website.
What a site addsThe enquiry from the person who will not ring — the nine o'clock one, from somebody who would rather type than talk. That is a real share of enquiries and a listing has nowhere to put it.
04
Only a site does this
Being understood before the first phone call
What you do and do not take on, what a job like theirs usually runs to, where you will and will not drive, what happens after they get in touch. A listing has room for none of it, so every one of those questions arrives as a phone call, and the ones that do not arrive are people who guessed and guessed wrong.
What a free Google listing doesA description of 750 characters. It is enough to say what you are. It is not enough to answer anything.
What a site addsThis is the first job on the list that a website is genuinely the only answer to, and it is the one that quietly saves you hours a week.
05
Only a site does this
Being something a customer can forward to somebody else
Half the jobs worth having are not decided by the person who rang you. There is a partner, a landlord, a body corporate, a committee, a manager who signs things off. That person wants a link, and what he does with it is decide whether you look like the safe option.
What a free Google listing doesNothing useful. Nobody forwards a map pin to a landlord.
What a site addsThe thing that gets sent on. If your work involves anybody having to be convinced who never speaks to you, this row on its own is the reason to build.
06
Not about customers
Being somewhere you own
A listing is Google's. The rules change, the layout changes, a profile can be suspended over something you did not do, and you cannot alter a line of how it looks. None of that is a reason to skip it — it is free and it works. It is a reason not to let it be the only place your business exists.
What a free Google listing doesEverything it does, on somebody else's terms, at somebody else's discretion.
What a site addsAn address that is yours, on a domain in your name, with the content in your hands. It is the only job on this list that is about the next ten years rather than next week.
Three of six is not a criticism of Google listings — it is an argument for getting one, and for not paying anybody four figures to do the part that is free. The whole of that job, and what it does not buy, is on the $395 page.